Newspaper page close up

Defamation Claims, Concerns Notices and the Serious Harm Test

Someone has written something about you online, or said it to a room full of people, and you’re furious. Your first thought might be to sue. But defamation claims in Australia have changed over the last few years, and there are now extra steps before you can start, plus a higher bar to get over.

The same goes if you’re on the other end and a letter has turned up accusing you of defaming someone. Either way it pays to understand the rules early. The law isn’t identical in every state and territory, so take this as a general guide, drawn from the Judicial Commission of NSW Civil Trials Bench Book.

Which law applies

Every state and territory has its own Defamation Act. The Judicial Commission of NSW bench book on defamation describes these Acts as substantially uniform. In New South Wales it’s the Defamation Act 2005, and the reforms made by the Defamation Amendment Act 2020 (NSW) commenced on 1 July 2021.

The bench book says the same reforms were made in Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, Tasmania and the ACT, with Tasmania’s starting a bit later, on 12 November 2021. The Northern Territory brought in its version on 11 August 2025, according to the Northern Territory Attorney-General’s Department. Western Australia hasn’t enacted the reforms yet, the bench book says. So which rules apply can depend on where something was published and when. A lawyer can tell you which version covers your situation.

To bring a claim, you have to prove a few things. The material has to have been published to someone other than you. It has to identify you and carry a defamatory meaning. And since the reforms, you also have to show serious harm to your reputation.

Serious harm

That last one came in through section 10A of the NSW Act. The bench book explains it’s now part of the cause of action itself, and it’s the court that decides whether serious harm is made out, not a jury. Damage also isn’t presumed anymore just because publication has been proved.

The idea was to weed out minor claims. A nasty comment that a handful of people saw might not get over the line. You’ll often need evidence of real effects on your reputation, and things like lost work, damaged relationships and how widely it spread can all be relevant. So not every insult counts. And even where there is serious harm, the publisher might have a defence, like honest opinion.

Concerns notices

Before you can sue, you have to serve a concerns notice on whoever you’re likely to sue. Section 12B of the NSW Act makes this a requirement. The bench book calls it a substantive requirement, not just a procedural step, and proceedings started without a valid notice may be struck out.

Section 12A sets out what has to be in the notice, including the imputations you’re relying on and particulars of the serious harm. Generally you can’t start proceedings until 28 days after the notice is served, unless the court gives leave. It can take longer if the publisher asks for further particulars.

The notice also gives both sides a chance to sort it out early. A publisher who gets one can make an offer to make amends under Part 3 of the Act, which has its own steps and timing rules. If you’re the person complaining, think carefully before knocking back a reasonable offer, because a refused reasonable offer can help the publisher’s defence later on.

Don’t sit on it

The time limits are short. In New South Wales, the Limitation Act 1969 gives you one year from the date of publication. The court can extend that by up to three years where it’s just and reasonable, but you don’t want to be relying on that. Waiting to see if it all blows over can cost you.

There’s also a single publication rule. Later publications of substantially the same material by the same publisher are generally treated as running from the first one. That matters a lot for stuff online that stays up for ages. Other states and territories have their own limitation laws, so check which ones apply to you.

If you’re the one being accused, there’s a range of defences a publisher can rely on. The bench book lists them by section number under the NSW Act:

  • justification, where the imputations are substantially true
  • contextual truth
  • absolute privilege
  • qualified privilege
  • publication about an issue of public interest under section 29A
  • honest opinion
  • innocent dissemination

Each one has its own requirements and the details make a big difference. The public interest defence in section 29A sits alongside the older ones, and which defence fits comes down to the facts. Businesses run into defamation risk through reviews and online posts. If your firm publishes regular content to bring in clients, as our SEO tips for law firms suggest, check anything you say about other people before it goes live.

Companies, juries and damages

Not everyone can sue. Section 9 of the NSW Act restricts certain corporations from bringing claims, and section 10 stops claims being brought on behalf of people who’ve died. If you own a business and someone’s criticised it, keep that in mind before you decide how to respond. A lawyer can check whether your particular business is able to sue at all.

A lot of business disputes are as much about contracts as reputation, and a clear agreement can cut down the chance of things blowing up in public later. Our post on non circumvention clauses in commercial contracts looks at one way to protect a business relationship. If you’re just starting out, our guide to legal documents for new landscaping companies might help too.

In New South Wales either side can elect for a jury under section 21. The jury decides whether defamatory material was published and whether a defence is made out, and then the judge decides damages. The bench book notes a jury normally has four members, and the Federal Court presumes a trial by judge alone.

Damages for non economic loss are capped under section 35. The cap started at $250,000 on 1 January 2006 and gets adjusted every year on 1 July. For publications after 1 July 2021 it works as a hard cap, kept for the most serious cases. Exemplary damages aren’t available, under section 37.

Defamation can come up in professional settings as well, health care included. Patients sometimes post about how their treatment went, and that can turn into a dispute. Our article on the legal implications of laser eye surgery looks at some related legal issues for patients and clinics.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Defamation laws differ between states and territories and they change over time. Please talk to a qualified lawyer about your own situation before you take any step.